Accidental inclusion

Off-topic or other-person content entered.

Who judgesClinician judgement
EvidenceGrade E1
Product typeAmbient scribesID S3

What accidental inclusion means

Off-topic or other-person content entered.

Why it matters. Content from another person or an off-topic aside can end up in the chart.

Example, illustrative

A remark about the clinician's holiday appears in the plan.

How to measure it

01

Collect visits

Use recorded or simulated visits with the source transcript.

02

Compare note to source

Check every fact in the visit against the note, and every claim in the note against the visit.

03

Grade severity

Clinicians rank each error by the harm it could do.

04

Stratify

Split results by specialty, accent and visit type.

Watch out for

Rates from different studies use different definitions and aren't comparable.

What a good report shows

A per-note error rate with severity bands, specialty splits and a named review instruction.

Report whether the rate is per sentence or per note, how notes were sampled, which review instruction clinicians were given, and the severity of each error. Rates from different studies are not comparable.

Reviewed by the Precision research team.

How strong is the evidence

E1 · Peer-reviewed, regulator, audit or court source. Backed by a peer-reviewed paper, a regulator, an audit or a court record. Usually read through a summary, not the full text.

What the sources say

JMIR 9.3% of notes.

  • Clinician judgement. Needs a clinician to judge or label, because the answer depends on clinical meaning.

Found something out of date? Write to hello@precision.example.

Quick answers

What is accidental inclusion in healthcare AI?

Off-topic or other-person content entered. It sits in the ambient scribes and clinical documentation group.

Why does accidental inclusion matter?

Content from another person or an off-topic aside can end up in the chart. A remark about the clinician's holiday appears in the plan.

How is accidental inclusion measured?

Collect visits, then Compare note to source, then Grade severity, then Stratify. Report whether the rate is per sentence or per note, how notes were sampled, which review instruction clinicians were given, and the severity of each error. Rates from different studies are not comparable.

What should I watch out for with accidental inclusion?

Rates from different studies use different definitions and aren't comparable. A good report gives: a per-note error rate with severity bands, specialty splits and a named review instruction.

Can accidental inclusion be automated?

Only in part. It needs clinician judgement. Software can screen, but a clinician must judge the cases that matter.

Measure accidental inclusion on your own data