Service · Head to head

Vendor bake-off

Choose between AI vendors using your own cases, not their demos.

Head to head · on local data

Same casesfor every vendor
Blindreviewers don't see whose output is whose
Rangesso small gaps aren't sold as wins
One pagea committee can read in five minutes
The problem

Every vendor demo looks great.

Demos use curated cases and vendor-run scores. Two scribes can both claim high accuracy while measuring different things, so numbers from different sources can't be compared.

Accuracy claims use different definitions

Demo cases are chosen to flatter

Procurement has no neutral test to point to

What has to happen

How it works.

Put every vendor through the same cases, graded by the same clinicians with the same rubric, and report the results with ranges so small gaps aren't mistaken for wins.

  1. 01

    Build a shared case set

    We assemble encounters that reflect your specialties, accents and edge cases.

  2. 02

    Run every vendor blind

    Each product processes the same cases. Reviewers don't see which vendor produced which output.

  3. 03

    Score with clinicians

    The same rubric and the same calibrated graders judge every output.

  4. 04

    Report with ranges

    Results show confidence ranges, error severity and where each vendor fails.

Head to head

Choose with evidence, not a demo.

Vendor accuracy numbers use different definitions and different cases.

CapabilityPrecision bake-offYour cases, blind reviewVendor-run benchmarkTheir cases, their methodPilot with anecdotesWhoever shouts loudestRFP questionnaireSelf-reported answers
Same cases for every vendorYesNoNoNot applicable
Blind to which vendorYesNoNoNo
Comparable definitionsOne rubricEach their ownVariesVaries
Shows uncertaintyRanges on every scoreSingle figureNoneNone
Reusable at renewalYesNoNoNo
Time to a decisionWeeksInstant but weakMonthsWeeks

Columns describe typical positions of each option, not named vendors. Check current terms before deciding.

What you get

What lands on your desk.

Indicative: three to five weeks, depending on vendor access.

Side-by-side scorecard

One page a committee can read in five minutes.

Failure examples

The actual outputs behind each number.

A decision memo

What the evidence supports and what it doesn't.

A reusable case set

Re-run it at renewal or when a vendor ships a new model.

Who it's for
  • Health systems buying scribes or voice agents
  • Groups running a pilot with two or three vendors
  • Procurement teams that need evidence for a committee
Pricing

Clear scope, clear price.

One price. Indicative pricing in US dollars. Final scope and price are confirmed on a short call.

Most chosen

Vendor bake-off

$2,999one-off

One price for your whole shortlist.

  • Shared case set for every vendor
  • Blind clinician review
  • Scorecard with ranges
  • Failure examples per vendor
  • Decision memo
Get a quote

Indicative pricing in US dollars. Final scope and price are confirmed on a short call. See all pricing

Will vendors cooperate?

Most agree when the buyer asks. We only need the same access a clinician would have, such as audio in and note out.

Is the result a ranking?

It's a scorecard with ranges. If two vendors are statistically close, we say so rather than force an order.

Can we publish the results?

That's your decision. By default the results belong to you.

Plan a vendor bake-off

Run AI vendors side by side on your own cases, not their demos.