PDQI-9 / modified PDQI-9
Nine to eleven criteria on 5-point Likert (accurate, thorough, organised, succinct, internally consistent).
What pdqi-9 / modified pdqi-9 means
Nine to eleven criteria on 5-point Likert (accurate, thorough, organised, succinct, internally consistent).
Why it matters. A shared checklist lets reviewers judge note quality the same way.
A note scores 4 of 5 for accuracy but 2 for organisation.
How to measure it
Collect visits
Use recorded or simulated visits with the source transcript.
Compare note to source
Check every fact in the visit against the note, and every claim in the note against the visit.
Grade severity
Clinicians rank each error by the harm it could do.
Stratify
Split results by specialty, accent and visit type.
Rates from different studies use different definitions and aren't comparable.
A per-note error rate with severity bands, specialty splits and a named review instruction.
Report whether the rate is per sentence or per note, how notes were sampled, which review instruction clinicians were given, and the severity of each error. Rates from different studies are not comparable.
Reviewed by the Precision research team.
How strong is the evidence
E2 · Preprint, benchmark page or vendor-run result. Backed by numbers from a preprint, a benchmark page or a vendor-run test. Treat as strong but not settled.
What the sources say
Palm: ambient better on thoroughness and organisation, worse on succinctness, consistency and accuracy; inter-rater RWG >0.7 but only moderate in paediatrics and cardiology; Suki-affiliated authors (Frontiers).
- Clinician judgement. Needs a clinician to judge or label, because the answer depends on clinical meaning.
- Frontiersfrontiersin.org
Found something out of date? Write to hello@precision.example.
Agents that measure this
Quick answers
What is pdqi-9 / modified pdqi-9 in healthcare AI?
Nine to eleven criteria on 5-point Likert (accurate, thorough, organised, succinct, internally consistent). It sits in the ambient scribes and clinical documentation group.
Why does pdqi-9 / modified pdqi-9 matter?
A shared checklist lets reviewers judge note quality the same way. A note scores 4 of 5 for accuracy but 2 for organisation.
How is pdqi-9 / modified pdqi-9 measured?
Collect visits, then Compare note to source, then Grade severity, then Stratify. Report whether the rate is per sentence or per note, how notes were sampled, which review instruction clinicians were given, and the severity of each error. Rates from different studies are not comparable.
What should I watch out for with pdqi-9 / modified pdqi-9?
Rates from different studies use different definitions and aren't comparable. A good report gives: a per-note error rate with severity bands, specialty splits and a named review instruction.
Can pdqi-9 / modified pdqi-9 be automated?
Only in part. It needs clinician judgement. Software can screen, but a clinician must judge the cases that matter.