Clinical Q&A quality.
Fluent answers built on stale or wrong guidance. Clinical Q&A tools answer a clinician's question in seconds, often with citations.
Next in line: we plan to offer this after the core focus areas.
Where clinical q&a breaks.
Clinical Q&A tools answer a clinician's question in seconds, often with citations. The risk is a confident, fluent answer built on outdated or wrong guidance.
Stale guidance
The answer cites a guideline that was replaced last year. It reads right and is wrong.
Citations that don't say that
A reference is attached, but the source doesn't support the claim.
Agrees too easily
When a user states something wrong, the tool goes along with it instead of correcting it.
Three steps, in the open.
Continuous head-to-head benchmarking on specialty questions; citation faithfulness; guideline-version regression.
- 01
Build a clinician question set
Your specialists write questions that reflect real decisions, including tricky ones.
- 02
Grade against rubrics
Answers are scored on clinician-written criteria, with guideline versions named.
- 03
Compare with a general model
We run the same questions through a general frontier model so you know what the specialised tool adds.
Head-to-head benchmarking.
Rubric grader, citation checks.
Who builds it, who buys it.
OpenEvidence ($12B per Jan 2026 round, >40% of US physicians reported), UpToDate Expert AI via Doximity, general labs' health products. Ad-supported or per-seat
The stakes
Vendors are well funded and often grade themselves. Independent, same-question comparisons give buyers something to rely on.
Rules and reading
Measure clinical q&a on your own data
What we measure for clinical q&a.
Rubric accuracy and completeness (clinician-facing)
HealthBench Professional: 525 tasks from a 15,079 pool, about one-third adversarial, rubrics adjudicated by three or more physicians
Task-category score
MedHELM: 121 tasks, 22 subcategories (decision support 0.56-0.72, note generation 0.73-0.85, patient comms 0.78-0.83 in the preprint; HAI article gives slightly different ranges)
Guideline concordance
Match to a named, versioned guideline
Citation and source faithfulness
Claims entailed by the cited source
Drug dose and interaction accuracy
Checked against FDA labels, RxNav
Sycophancy to clinician or patient assertions
Adversarial rubrics
Common questions.
How do you grade open-ended answers?
With clinician-written rubrics that award or deduct points for specific facts. An AI grader scores them, and we report how often it disagrees with clinicians.
Is this regulated as a medical device?
It can be, depending on the function and audience. See our regulation pages for the current US position.
Can you test citations?
Yes. We check whether each cited source supports the claim it's attached to.
Know your healthcare AI is safe to trust
before it reaches a patient.
Book a 30-minute call. We'll look at your product and tell you what we would measure first.
hello@precision.example