Section 1557 and AI decision tools: what 92.210 requires

Section 1557's rule makes covered entities identify decision tools that use protected characteristics and mitigate discrimination risk. Dates and limits.

  • US

145 CFR 92.210 applies to patient-care decision support tools, including AI, used by entities covered by Section 1557.

2The duty has two parts: identify tools that use race, sex, age, disability or other protected characteristics as inputs, and make reasonable efforts to mitigate discrimination risk.

3The identification duty took effect on 1 May 2025; enforcement is case by case and OCR's January 2025 Dear Colleague letter says 1557 applies to AI.

4ONC cited 45 CFR 92.210 as one of the remaining backstops when it removed predictive-tool transparency requirements in HTI-5.

Limits of this page. We did not read the rule text or OCR's letter; this page rests on a Manatt summary and ONC's reference to the rule. We found no enforcement actions or guidance on what counts as 'reasonable efforts' in 2026.

What does 45 CFR 92.210 require?

It is the part of the Section 1557 nondiscrimination rule that covers patient-care decision support tools. Covered entities must identify tools that use protected characteristics as inputs and must make reasonable efforts to mitigate the risk of discrimination from those tools.

When did it take effect?

The identification duty took effect on 1 May 2025. OCR’s Dear Colleague letter of January 2025 says Section 1557 applies to AI. Enforcement is case by case, and we found no enforcement action in 2026.

What counts as a protected characteristic?

The rule covers characteristics protected under Section 1557 such as race, colour, national origin, sex, age and disability. A tool can use them directly or through proxies, so measurement should look at subgroup error, not only whether a field is an input.

Part of the duty What to show
Identify tools An inventory of decision tools and their inputs
Assess risk Subgroup performance with confidence intervals
Mitigate A documented fix or a monitoring plan

Why does it matter now?

When ONC removed predictive-tool transparency requirements in HTI-5, it pointed to FDA oversight and 45 CFR 92.210 as remaining backstops. See the HTI-5 final rule.

What did we not verify?

The rule text, what OCR treats as reasonable efforts, and any 2026 enforcement. Small subgroups give wide intervals, so say so.

Frequently asked questions

Does Section 1557 apply to AI tools?

Yes, according to OCR's January 2025 Dear Colleague letter. The rule at 45 CFR 92.210 covers patient-care decision support tools, which includes AI-based tools used by covered entities.

What must a hospital do under 92.210?

It must identify patient-care decision support tools that use protected characteristics as inputs and make reasonable efforts to mitigate the risk of discrimination. The identification duty took effect on 1 May 2025.

How is compliance measured?

The rule asks for reasonable efforts, not a specific metric, and enforcement is case by case. Subgroup error rates with confidence intervals are one way to show you looked, but the rule does not prescribe them.

Sources

  1. HHS finalizes antidiscrimination rules on patient care decision support toolsManatt
  2. Dear Colleague letter: Section 1557 and artificial intelligenceHHS Office for Civil Rights · 2025-01
  3. ONC finalizes a significantly narrower rule for health IT certificationEpstein Becker Green · 2026-10

Found something out of date? Write to hello@precision.example and we will fix it.

Written and reviewed byPrecision research teamHealthcare AI evaluation research